Dr Hilary Cass has said she does not support the draft conversion practices bill in its current wording, warning that it could create “serious unintended consequences” for parents and therapists. Her intervention is significant because she led the independent review of gender care for children and young people in England, a process that has shaped the current debate over clinical practice, safeguarding and the limits of lawful discussion around gender identity.
Cass, a consultant paediatrician, authored the final report of the Independent Review of Gender Identity Services for Children and Young People, widely known as the Cass Review. Commissioned by NHS England, the review examined how services should respond to children and adolescents experiencing gender-related distress. Its findings placed emphasis on evidence, multidisciplinary care and the need to avoid narrowing complex clinical conversations into predetermined outcomes.
The draft bill concerns conversion practices, a term generally used for attempts to change or suppress a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity. Measures to prohibit such practices have been debated for years in the United Kingdom, with campaigners arguing that legal protection is needed against coercive or abusive conduct. The difficulty for lawmakers has been how to define prohibited behaviour without restricting legitimate therapy, medical assessment, pastoral support or parental conversations.
Cass’s concern is focused on the language of the proposal, not on support for harmful or coercive practices. By stating that she cannot back the bill as drafted, she has highlighted a central challenge in this area of policy: legislation must be precise enough to protect vulnerable people while allowing clinicians and families to address distress, uncertainty and coexisting mental health needs. For therapists, unclear wording could affect how they explore a young person’s circumstances; for parents, it could raise fears about ordinary discussion being misinterpreted.
The warning adds weight to scrutiny of the bill before any final legal text is adopted. It also underlines the continuing influence of the Cass Review on public policy, beyond the organisation of NHS services. Any legislation in this field will have to balance protection from abuse with access to careful, evidence-based support. Dr Hilary Cass’s position places that balance at the centre of the debate over how a ban should be written and applied.


