More
    - Advertisement - spot_img
    HomeNewsCan the Sumud Flotilla Make a Difference?

    Can the Sumud Flotilla Make a Difference?

    By Aissa Boukanoun*

    At the end of August and the beginning of September 2025, a coalition of civilian vessels, including retrofitted fishing boats and other small ships, is scheduled to depart from ports in Spain, Tunisia, and elsewhere in the Mediterranean. The initiative, called the Global Sumud Flotilla (GSF), “sumud” meaning steadfastness in Arabic, is described by its coordinators as a gesture of solidarity with Gaza’s population. Public gatherings are planned at departure ports, where some participants will take part only in the send-off, while others intend to sail into international waters.

    Organizers say the flotilla will carry medical supplies, food, and an international delegation of professionals such as doctors, lawyers, journalists, and politicians. More than 6,000 people from over 40 countries have registered to participate, either on board or through parallel events on land. Participants are reportedly receiving training in nonviolent resistance, media interaction, and de-escalation methods. “We stand with the people of Palestine,” said one GSF representative, framing the flotilla as a symbolic message of international attention on Gaza.

    Travel times vary depending on departure points, with experts estimating seven to ten days from Spain and three to five from Tunisia. In practice, however, the duration is unlikely to be dictated by navigation alone, as the outcome will largely depend on the timing and circumstances of an expected interception.

    According to organizers, the flotilla is financed mainly through small donations and participant contributions, with no central budget publicly revealed. They present it as a volunteer-driven initiative.

    The group describes its members as a broad mix of civil society actors from multiple countries. While well-known figures such as Greta Thunberg, listed on the flotilla’s steering committee, are involved, most participants are less prominent individuals motivated by a shared humanitarian commitment.

    The blockade of Gaza, in place since 2007, remains one of the region’s most contested policies. Israel, with limited collaboration from Egypt at the Rafah border, maintains that the restrictions are necessary to prevent weapons smuggling and attacks, while Egypt takes a cautious approach, occasionally permitting humanitarian crossings.

    Critics, including UN agencies and human rights groups, describe the blockade as a form of collective punishment, citing widespread shortages of food, medicine, clean water, and electricity, as well as the reliance of over 80% of Gaza’s population on aid.

    The debate also extends to legal interpretations. Flotilla organizers proclaim their mission is lawful under international law, viewing the blockade itself as illegal. Israeli officials counter that the San Remo Manual on naval warfare, a widely recognized guide on the conduct of armed conflicts at sea, permits enforcement of the blockade and interception of ships, even in international waters. Israeli authorities have further suggested in the past, without releasing public evidence, that flotilla organizers may have links to Hamas. Organizers reject these allegations, emphasizing that their initiative is focused solely on humanitarian issues and human rights advocacy.

    Organizers and participants acknowledge that interception by the Israeli navy is the most likely outcome. The stated aim, according to activists, is less about reaching Gaza directly than about drawing international attention to the blockade. “The journey itself is the point,” said one activist, arguing that each interception highlights questions about the legality and morality of the blockade.

    Risks for participants remain significant. Organizers have provided no information on essential aspects such as insurance coverage. In activities of this nature, participants are generally expected to have their own insurance. In Europe, most individual travel insurance policies do not cover travel to conflict zones and require specialized coverage, often exorbitantly expensive, including reimbursement for injuries and repatriation. How the organizers have addressed this critical issue, both for participants and equipment, remains unknown. Attempts to obtain clarification from the flotilla’s press office have so far gone unanswered.

    Past incidents underline these concerns. In 2010, an Israeli raid on the vessel Mavi Marmara resulted in ten deaths. More recently, in June 2025, the boats Madleen, which carried activists Greta Thunberg and Rima Hassan, and Handala, were intercepted without violence and diverted to the Israeli port of Ashdod.

    According to Israeli procedures, those intercepted are typically taken to Ashdod, charged with attempting to enter Israel illegally, detained, and later deported with bans of up to 10 years. Vessels are generally confiscated. Challenges have also arisen on land: in June 2025, a convoy from Tunisia to Gaza was halted in Libya, while activists who attempted to enter Egypt on tourist visas were deported after authorities determined they had concealed their humanitarian intentions.

    European and other Western governments have not prohibited their citizens from participating, as doing so could raise legal and human rights concerns. Instead, they have issued advisories warning citizens of the risks of interception, detention, and deportation.

    While the flotilla remains a nonviolent, solidarity-driven initiative, the exact volume of aid and number of medical personnel on board remain unclear. Organizers stress that the mission is meant to raise international awareness rather than successfully breach the blockade.

    Israel, citing security concerns, considers any attempt to reach Gaza by sea a potential violation of international law and retains the right to intercept vessels. The flotilla’s credibility depends on maintaining nonpartisan, humanitarian objectives, avoiding political or ideological entanglements that could dilute its message. Since

    the October 7, 2023 Hamas attacks on southern Israel, which left over 1,200 Israelis dead and 251 abducted, and the subsequent Israeli military response that has caused tens of thousands of Palestinian deaths, the conflict has intensified dramatically. In this context of ongoing violence and humanitarian crisis, can this flotilla make a meaningful difference compared with previous attempts?


    cropped Aissa Bouknoun e1756417103280.jpg

    *Aissa Boukanoun is an independent bilingual journalist, conference interpreter, and translator based in Brussels, accredited by European institutions. He has extensive experience as a correspondent and war reporter, covering high-risk areas across the MENA region. He has contributed to major international media outlets and is recognized for his investigative work, providing clear and detailed insights into complex global events. He is also the French translator of the autobiographical book Qatar à travers mes yeux, originally written in Arabic by Sheikh Faisal Bin Qassim Al Thani, a prominent Qatari businessman and philanthropist who supports charitable and social causes.

    ———-

    First published in this link of The European Times.

    spot_img

    Must Read

    spot_img